The most expensive thing about your office printer isn't the printer. It's the 15 minutes here, the 20 minutes there that your team spends trying to make it do what the box promised.
I've managed our print and office equipment budget—$42,000 annually across a 180-person company—for six years. I've negotiated with more than 20 vendors, and I've signed off on every invoice since 2019. When I audited our 2023 spending, I found something that still bothers me: we spent more on “printer workarounds” than on the printers themselves.
Not toner. Not paper. Workarounds.
The fax feature nobody asked for—and nobody knows how to use
We bought a Brother all-in-one in early 2023. It had fax, scan, copy, the whole thing. I assumed “fax-capable” meant people would fax. Didn't verify. Turned out half the team couldn't tell the difference between “fax” and “scan-to-email,” and the other half were too polite to admit it.
Our front desk manager sort of became the accidental fax expert. Every time a client needed a signed document sent to a landline—yes, some industries still do this—she'd spend 10 to 15 minutes walking someone through the menu. I pulled the numbers from our IT ticketing system: 7 fax-related tickets per month in Q1 2023, averaging 22 minutes each. That's 154 minutes a month, or roughly 31 hours a year, spent on a feature we “already had.”
At our internal loaded rate of $38/hour, that's about $1,180 annually. The printer's depreciation was $340 that year.
And here's the part that stung: when I searched our internal knowledge base, the top query wasn't “how to fax” or “fax settings.” It was people Googling how to use fax on brother printer on their phones because our own documentation was a 40-page PDF nobody opened.
The most frustrating part wasn't the feature itself. It was that we'd paid for it, installed it, and then quietly taxed every employee who needed it. You'd think a fax button would be self-explanatory. It wasn't.
“Can I print from my iPad?” is a budget question
Same pattern, different feature. Our sales team works from iPads. In Q2 2023, three of them asked why they couldn't print contracts directly from the device. I said, “Just use the app.” There was no app. Or rather, there was, but nobody had set it up.
I assumed “wireless printing” meant “wireless printing from anything.” Wrong assumption. Connecting a Brother printer to an iPad isn't hard—you need the right app, the printer on the same network, and about five minutes of patience. But five minutes × 12 salespeople × once a week adds up.
Let me do the math the way I should have done it before the purchase: 12 people, 20 minutes each per week (including the “why isn't this working” phase), 48 working weeks. That's 192 hours a year. At a $45/hour loaded rate for sales staff, that's $8,640 in lost selling time.
The printer cost $280.
I'm not saying the printer was a bad choice. I'm saying the purchase decision stopped at the price tag, and the real bill showed up in calendar blocks labeled “IT help.”
The counterintuitive part: cheaper models often cost more to learn
Here's where my thinking shifted. We compared two models in late 2023—one $80 cheaper than the other. Same print speed, same paper capacity, similar footprint. I almost bought the cheaper one.
Then I looked at setup time. The cheaper model's fax configuration took our IT contractor 90 minutes to get right. The $80-more model took 15 minutes. At $75/hour for the contractor, that's $112.50 versus $18.75. The “cheaper” machine was actually $13.75 more expensive before it printed a single page.
That's not a huge number. But it's the kind of number that repeats every time someone new joins the company and needs to be walked through the settings. And it's the kind of number that never shows up in a vendor quote.
“We stopped comparing sticker prices after that. Now we compare ‘time to first useful print'—how long it takes a new employee to do the thing they actually need to do.”
“But we're a 12-person shop—does this really matter?”
Yes, and arguably more. In a 180-person company, 31 hours a year on fax confusion is annoying. In a 12-person company, it's the owner spending two hours on a Saturday trying to figure out why the phone line isn't connecting, instead of doing sales calls.
The math scales down, but the opportunity cost scales up. Small teams don't have an IT department to absorb the friction. The person who can't connect the iPad is also the person who handles payroll.
I've heard the counterargument: “Just buy the simplest printer and skip the features.” That works until a client asks for a fax. Then you're driving to an office supply store at 4:50 PM on a Friday. I've done that. Not again.
What I actually track now
When we evaluate a printer in 2025, I don't start with the unit price. I start with three questions:
- How long does it take a new hire to complete the three most common tasks—print, scan, fax—without asking anyone?
- Does it connect to the devices our team actually uses, or just the ones in the spec sheet?
- When it breaks, how many minutes pass before a human answers the phone?
Those answers don't fit neatly into a purchase order. But they show up in the budget eventually—as overtime, as missed deadlines, as the quiet resentment of the person who's been designated “the printer person.”
The Brother printer on my desk is fine. It prints. It scans. It faxes, apparently. But the reason I kept it isn't the cost per page.
It's that the setup took 15 minutes, and nobody has filed a ticket since.
That's the number I should've been comparing all along.